The provider line is the largest cost under the price, so the pay model is a margin decision
Contribution margin on one visit is the price minus materials by the dose, the provider's cost for that visit, the room and the waste, the method in the unit economics guide. The provider line is the one the pay model moves. Under hourly pay it is a fixed cost per minute booked, under commission a share of whatever price was charged, and the other two sit between. The model decides who absorbs a discount, who is paid for an empty hour, and whether a longer consult costs the practice or the provider.
Four models, one formula, a different provider line in each
| Model | The provider line on one visit | Who absorbs a discount | What it does to an open hour |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hourly | Loaded hourly cost times the minutes booked | The practice, all of it | The hour costs the same empty or full, so filling it is the owner's job |
| Commission on revenue | A share of the price charged | Both; the injector loses their share of the cut | The injector wants it filled and may trade a discount for a booking |
| Hybrid: base plus a share | A base per hour plus a smaller share, often above a threshold | Mostly the practice below the threshold, both above it | Steady pay for the quiet month; the share rewards the busy one |
| Flat per treatment | A fixed amount per visit regardless of price | The practice, all of it | Short visits pay the same as long ones, so consults and complex visits get squeezed |
How each model changes behavior on the calendar
- Hourly: the injector is paid whether the 2 pm slot fills or not, so the empty slot belongs to the front desk and the comeback message. Utilization, booked minutes divided by paid hours, is the number to watch.
- Commission: pay rises with price and volume, so the book fills and the ticket grows, and so does the pull toward a discount that closes a wavering patient. Discount share by provider is the number to watch.
- Hybrid: the base covers the slow month and the share rewards the full one, which keeps a good injector through a quiet quarter. Set the threshold from last year's revenue per provider hour.
- Flat per treatment: fast visits earn the same as slow ones, so the model rewards speed and punishes the forty-minute consult that becomes a three-visit patient. Consult-to-treatment conversion by provider is the number to watch.
A worked example, labeled illustrative
Say a neurotoxin visit, tox from here on, is priced at $500 in this illustrative example. Product, waste and consumables in the example are $160 and the room $15, leaving $325 before the provider line. In this example, hourly pay of $60 loaded for the hour leaves $265. A thirty percent commission, $150 in the example, leaves $175. The example's hybrid, $35 for the hour plus a ten percent share, $85, leaves $240, and its flat $100 a visit leaves $225. Now say the same visit sells at a $400 party price. Under hourly the margin in this example falls to $165 and under the flat rate to $125; the practice absorbed the whole $100. Under commission in the same example the share falls to $120 and the margin to $105, so the injector gave up $30 of the discount and the practice gave up $70. Replace every figure with your own.
The numbers to run before choosing
- Revenue per provider hour: revenue by provider divided by hours paid, by month, for twelve months.
- Utilization: minutes booked divided by minutes paid, by provider and by week.
- Average price per visit and discount share by provider, from the point-of-sale export. A high discount share under commission is the pay model discounting for you.
- Materials and waste by provider, from the opened-vial log. Commission on revenue pays the same share whether the vial was used well or not.
- Consult-to-treatment conversion by provider: consults that became a treatment within thirty days, divided by consults.
- Contribution margin after the provider line, per visit, under each model, from the numbers above and your cost list. Pick the model from that column, then check that the pay keeps the injector.
What to confirm with counsel and your accountant
Wage and classification rules reach every one of these models, and they differ by state and change. Whether an injector is an employee or a contractor, how a commission is written and paid, and what a pay change requires in writing are questions for counsel. So are what happens to a commission when a package is refunded or a membership credit is spent, and how overtime and minimum pay interact with a share. The accounting of each is for your accountant, and nothing on this page states a rule. Supervision, delegation and who may inject are questions for your medical director and your state board.
How to run this on Monday
- Export twelve months of completed appointments by provider with booked minutes, and the payroll hours for the same months.
- Pull the discount share by provider from the point of sale for the same period and put it beside revenue per provider hour.
- Run the illustrative example with your own tox visit and your own four pay numbers; the column that stays widest after a discount is your answer.
- Book the counsel and accountant questions before the model changes.
What to do next
NorthCore's Know your numbers solution puts revenue per provider hour, utilization and discount share by provider on one page, from your record system and the paid hours you give it. The pay model is then chosen from a column, scoped in writing and covered by the promise on this site: results in 90 days, or we keep working until you have them.
